As Australian employers prepare for 2027, salary negotiations are becoming an increasingly important intersection of recruitment strategy, employee retention and legal compliance. While organisations must balance remuneration expectations against financial realities, they cannot overlook their obligations under Australian employment law.
In recent commentary published by HR Leader, Patrick Will of Liquid Employment Lawyers highlighted the risks of undervaluing employees and the importance of transparent, defensible remuneration practices. His observations reflect a broader challenge for employers: ensuring pay decisions are commercially sustainable without creating avoidable legal exposure or undermining employee trust.
Minimum entitlements are non-negotiable
Employers have considerable discretion when determining salaries, but that discretion operates within a statutory framework. The Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act), National Employment Standards (NES), applicable modern awards and enterprise agreements establish minimum employment entitlements that must be respected.
Before making an offer, employers should verify the relevant award or agreement, classification, minimum rate and applicable allowances, penalty rates and overtime obligations. A salary above the headline award rate does not automatically establish compliance. The employee’s actual hours, duties and applicable industrial instrument may also need to be considered.
Patrick identifies underpayment as one of the most significant risks associated with inadequate remuneration. Since 1 January 2025, intentional underpayment of wages and certain other employee entitlements can constitute a criminal offence under the federal workplace relations framework, subject to the applicable statutory requirements and exceptions. Honest mistakes are not, by themselves, criminal underpayment offences.
Employers should therefore establish a compliant remuneration baseline before negotiating discretionary increases or alternative benefits. A salary negotiation cannot lawfully replace an entitlement an employee is already owed.
Transparent pay decisions reduce legal and commercial risk
A documented, defensible salary range gives employers a consistent basis for assessing candidates and existing employees. Patrick recommends considering the relevant classification and market value of a role alongside the cost of recruitment, an unfilled position and the potential contribution of the person being hired.
Benchmarking should draw on reliable, relevant sources. These may include Fair Work Commission annual wage review decisions, applicable award rates and reputable industry salary surveys or recruitment guides that reflect the relevant sector and region.
Employers should also explain, at an appropriate level, how remuneration bands are determined. This can help manage expectations and reduce the perception that salary decisions are arbitrary.
Transparency is particularly important given Australia’s pay secrecy protections. Sections 333B–333D of the FW Act provide employees with rights to disclose their remuneration, ask other employees about remuneration and discuss certain employment conditions relevant to remuneration outcomes. Employers should ensure their contracts and workplace practices respect these rights.
Pay decisions must also comply with applicable anti-discrimination laws. Section 351 of the FW Act prohibits adverse action because of specified protected attributes, subject to statutory exceptions. Consistent criteria and documented reasons for remuneration decisions can help employers identify unexplained differences and assess whether their practices create discrimination risks.
Clear offers and realistic promises matter
Disputes can arise when candidates misunderstand what an employer is offering. A remuneration package should clearly distinguish base salary, superannuation, allowances, bonuses, commissions and other benefits. Any variable or discretionary components should be identified, with relevant eligibility criteria and conditions explained.
Employers should also take care when discussing future salary increases. If a potential increase depends on business performance, funding or agreed objectives, those conditions should be communicated clearly rather than presented as a guaranteed outcome.
Patrick recommends providing candidates and employees with a Total Rewards Statement setting out the financial value of their remuneration and benefits. Used appropriately, this can help employees understand the overall package without obscuring the distinction between guaranteed salary, statutory entitlements and discretionary benefits.
Clear employment contracts and remuneration policies should support these communications. Written terms should accurately reflect what was offered and agreed.
Alternatives to salary increases must respect minimum entitlements
When immediate salary increases are not financially viable, employers can explore professional development, mentorship, flexible working arrangements and additional benefits. Performance-linked bonuses or profit-sharing arrangements may also provide a pathway to higher earnings, provided their terms are clear and applicable legal obligations are met.
However, non-monetary benefits are not a substitute for lawful remuneration. Employers cannot simply trade away NES minimum entitlements in exchange for discretionary perks. Any proposed arrangement involving additional leave, flexibility or alternative remuneration must be assessed against the applicable legislation, industrial instrument and employment contract.
Customised benefits may also create administrative complexity or perceptions of unfairness if employees do not understand the criteria for accessing them. Employers should consider both the value of an initiative and how consistently and transparently it can be administered.
Patrick agrees to separate performance discussions from salary reviews. Regular conversations about performance, development and career progression can help manage expectations throughout the year, rather than concentrating every concern in a single annual remuneration discussion.
Gender pay gaps make consistency more important
Remuneration practices are also subject to greater scrutiny. The Workplace Gender Equality Agency (WGEA) publishes employer gender pay gap data, increasing the visibility of differences in remuneration outcomes.
A gender pay gap does not, by itself, establish unlawful discrimination. Nevertheless, employers should examine whether discretionary bonuses, allowances, starting salaries or negotiation practices produce unexplained disparities. Clear criteria, consistent decision-making and periodic remuneration reviews can help identify issues requiring further investigation.
Practical steps for employers preparing for 2027
Employers and HR professionals should:
- Verify compliance: Review awards, enterprise agreements, classifications and minimum entitlements before negotiating pay.
- Benchmark systematically: Use reliable industry data and maintain documented remuneration ranges.
- Communicate clearly: Separate base salary, superannuation, variable remuneration and benefits in written offers.
- Document decisions: Record the rationale for material remuneration decisions and apply established criteria consistently.
- Review pay equity: Investigate unexplained differences in salary, bonuses and other remuneration.
- Manage expectations year-round: Hold regular performance and career development discussions and explain the conditions attached to future opportunities.
Conclusion
Salary negotiations are not simply a question of how much an organisation can afford to pay. They require employers to balance commercial priorities with minimum employment obligations, workplace rights and fair, transparent decision-making.
As Patrick Will’s commentary highlights, a structured approach to remuneration can help businesses attract and retain talent while reducing the risk of underpayment, disputes and reputational damage. Reviewing salary frameworks and employment documentation before the next remuneration cycle is a practical step towards achieving that balance.
Liquid Employment Lawyers advises employers on remuneration compliance, employment contracts and workplace relations. Contact our team for advice on reviewing your organisation’s remuneration practices and managing employment law risks.

