Human resources professionals are entrusted with managing workplace conduct, handling sensitive complaints and ensuring organisations meet their employment obligations. But what happens when the people responsible for enforcing those standards are themselves accused of misconduct?
Recent high-profile incidents have brought this question into focus. In Australia, the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has commenced civil penalty proceedings against the former chief executive of Super Retail Group, alleging failures to disclose and manage conflicts of interest arising from an alleged relationship with a senior executive. Separately, public incidents involving senior HR executives at Bupa and Astronomer have prompted wider discussion about accountability, professional conduct and organisational oversight.
These situations raise an important issue for employers: misconduct involving senior HR personnel is not simply an individual employment matter. It can expose weaknesses in governance, reporting structures and the organisation’s ability to manage workplace risks independently.
Accountability extends beyond the individual
Senior HR professionals are employees and remain subject to workplace policies, contractual obligations and procedural fairness. Their position does not make them immune from investigation or disciplinary action.
However, responsibility does not end with the individual. CEOs and boards retain responsibility for organisational oversight, risk management and workplace culture. As Patrick Will of Liquid Employment Lawyers observes, HR is a function of the business, not a substitute for executive accountability.
This distinction is particularly important where the person implicated ordinarily manages complaints, investigations or employee records. If the head of HR is involved, the organisation should appoint an independent decision-maker outside their reporting line.
Employers should also consider whether the circumstances trigger broader legal or regulatory obligations. Under section 47C of the Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) (SD Act), employers and persons conducting a business or undertaking must take reasonable and proportionate measures to eliminate specified forms of unlawful sex discrimination, sexual harassment, sex-based harassment, hostile workplace environments and victimisation, as far as possible.
Work health and safety obligations may also arise where conduct creates risks to workers’ psychological health. For listed entities, the board should assess whether developments require disclosure under ASX Listing Rule 3.1, which concerns information that a reasonable person would expect to have a material effect on the price or value of securities.
When does private conduct become an employment issue?
Employers do not have an unrestricted right to regulate employees’ private lives. However, conduct outside working hours may justify disciplinary action where there is a sufficient connection with employment.
In Rose v Telstra Corporation Ltd [1998] AIRC 1592, the Commission considered whether an employee’s out-of-hours conduct provided a valid reason for dismissal. The decision illustrates that private conduct must have a sufficiently serious connection with the employment relationship, such that it could seriously damage that relationship, the employer’s interests or the employee’s ability to perform their duties.
For senior executives and HR leaders, the nature of the role may be relevant. Someone responsible for enforcing organisational standards may face particular questions about credibility and judgement if their own conduct appears inconsistent with those responsibilities. Nevertheless, seniority alone does not establish a valid reason for dismissal.
Employment contracts may contain provisions addressing conduct that damages an employer’s reputation or brings the organisation into disrepute. Senior executive agreements may also include codes of conduct, incentive forfeiture provisions and other contractual consequences. However, the existence of a reputation clause does not automatically make termination lawful. The wording, circumstances, employment connection and applicable dismissal protections must still be considered.
Workplace relationships require conflict management, not moral policing
Consensual workplace relationships are not generally prohibited by Australian employment law. The legal and organisational risks arise where relationships create actual or perceived conflicts of interest, particularly where one person has influence over another’s remuneration, promotion, performance management or continued employment.
Patrick argues that relationship disclosure policies should operate as conflict-of-interest controls rather than moral standards. This is particularly important for senior employees, where ordinary reporting channels may be ineffective.
For example, where a relationship involves the CEO or head of HR, disclosure should be capable of being made directly to the board chair or an appropriate board committee. Independent oversight can then address reporting lines, decision-making authority and access to confidential information.
Power imbalances also require careful consideration. Under the SD Act, sexual harassment and related unlawful conduct can arise in workplace contexts, and an employer’s positive duty requires proactive prevention. A consensual relationship is not automatically sexual harassment, but the surrounding circumstances, including authority and potential pressure, may require closer examination.
Responding to allegations: independence, evidence and procedural fairness
When allegations involve a senior HR professional, the first response should focus on preserving evidence and protecting the integrity of the investigation. Patrick recommends immediately reviewing the individual’s access to personnel files, investigation records and internal communications. Restricting or suspending access may be appropriate where there is a genuine risk of interference, provided the response is proportionate and properly managed.
The organisation should identify who needs to be informed, appoint an independent investigator and assess any regulatory or reporting obligations. It should also distinguish between a protected whistleblower disclosure and an unauthorised disclosure to the media.
Under Part 9.4AAA of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth), qualifying whistleblower disclosures receive statutory protections, including protection against victimisation and certain protections concerning identity. A disclosure to a journalist is not automatically protected: public interest and emergency disclosures are subject to specific statutory conditions.
Even during a public controversy, the person accused must be given a proper opportunity to respond to the allegations before findings are made. If allegations are substantiated, the appropriate outcome may range from counselling or a formal warning to dismissal for serious misconduct, depending on the evidence, contractual terms and circumstances.
Legal professional privilege should also be considered when planning an investigation. However, commissioning an investigation through external lawyers does not automatically make the resulting report privileged. The dominant purpose must satisfy the applicable legal test, as explained by the High Court in Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation [1999] HCA 67.
Building reporting systems that work independently
A reporting process is only effective if employees trust it and can use it without fear of retaliation. Organisations should provide multiple reporting channels, including an independent external option, and establish clear escalation pathways for allegations involving executives or HR personnel.
Patrick recommends that boards receive de-identified information about reports, investigation timeframes, outcomes and retaliation concerns. This allows directors to assess whether reporting systems are working and identify recurring organisational risks.
Policies should also establish how complaints are triaged. A personal grievance, a potential whistleblower disclosure and a psychosocial hazard may require different legal responses. Treating every report as the same type of issue risks overlooking compulsory statutory obligations.
Importantly, employers should not assume that every person who knows about an undisclosed relationship automatically has a legal duty to report it. However, organisations can establish clear internal reporting expectations and take reasonable steps to prevent and respond to workplace misconduct.
Practical steps for employers and boards
Organisations should consider whether they have the following:
- Independent investigation pathways for allegations involving senior HR personnel and executives.
- Clear relationship disclosure and conflict-of-interest policies.
- Appropriate controls over access to confidential employee records during investigations.
- Multiple reporting channels, including direct escalation to the board where necessary.
- Documented procedures for assessing whistleblower disclosures, workplace grievances and psychosocial risks.
- A process for assessing regulatory and ASX disclosure obligations.
- Regular board oversight of reporting trends, investigation outcomes and potential retaliation.
Conclusion
High-profile incidents involving HR professionals highlight the importance of accountability at every level of an organisation. Individual misconduct must be addressed fairly, but employers must also examine whether their governance arrangements, reporting channels and workplace controls are capable of identifying and managing problems independently.
As Patrick’s commentary highlights, the real test of an organisation’s policies is whether they work when the person responsible for enforcing them is the subject of the complaint.
Liquid Employment Lawyers advises and assists employers to conduct workplace investigations, manage executive conduct and conflicts of interest, and employment law compliance. Contact our team for advice on strengthening your organisation’s governance and workplace reporting processes.
As featured in HR Leader
This legal analysis builds on commentary from Patrick Will of Liquid Employment Lawyers, featured in HR Leader’s article, Good HR gone bad – who is responsible when HR are in hot water?
Read the original article to explore Patrick’s insights alongside perspectives from other employment law professionals.

