Multi-million-dollar executive departure payments frequently attract public criticism, particularly when senior leaders leave following governance failures or allegations of misconduct. To shareholders and employees, these payments can appear to reward failure. However, the legal position is often more complicated.
A recent article by HR Leaderand Accounting Times, featuring commentary from Patrick Will of Liquid Employment Lawyers, examined the departure payments received by former KPMG Australia leaders Andrew Yates and Martin Sheppard following governance and cultural failures at the firm. Although reported amounts included substantial deductions, their remaining payments raised questions about the distinction between contractual entitlements and discretionary exit bonuses.
The central issue for employers and boards is whether executives can legitimately retain substantial payments despite being implicated in organisational wrongdoing, and what mechanisms are available to ensure accountability.
Understanding what a golden handshake actually includes
A substantial departure payment does not necessarily represent a discretionary bonus or reward for leaving. For senior executives, it may comprise several different entitlements, including payment in lieu of notice, accrued leave, deferred remuneration, vested equity and retirement benefits.
As Patrick explains, executives in large organisations may have contractual notice periods of six to 12 months, alongside accumulated financial interests in the business. In professional services partnerships, capital and retirement entitlements can also contribute significantly to the final amount.
The distinction matters because employers cannot automatically withhold amounts that have already become legally payable simply because an executive’s departure attracts negative publicity.
For example, accrued annual leave generally remains payable when employment ends, including following dismissal for serious misconduct. The entitlement to notice, however, may be affected where a valid summary dismissal occurs.
Consequently, the total value of an exit package should not be confused with the amount an organisation has voluntarily paid as compensation for an executive’s departure.
The Corporations Act and restrictions on executive termination benefits
The Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Corporations Act) establishes restrictions on certain benefits provided when executives leave their positions.
Under section 200B of the Corporations Act, a company or relevant entity generally requires member approval before providing a benefit connected with the retirement of a person from a managerial or executive office, subject to statutory exceptions.
Sections 200F and 200G of the Corporations Act provide important exemptions, including certain leave payments, contractual benefits and qualifying payments for past services, subject to prescribed conditions and limits.
This framework is more nuanced than a blanket prohibition on large termination payments. The legal treatment depends on the nature of the payment, the executive’s position, the relevant period of service and whether an exemption applies.
For boards, this means that contractual obligations and statutory approval requirements must be considered together when negotiating an executive’s departure.
The Corporations Act also imposes separate duties on directors and officers. Sections 180 to183 of the Corporations Act address care and diligence, good faith, proper use of position and proper use of information. Where misconduct involves a breach of these duties, separate regulatory or civil consequences may arise. However, a potential breach does not automatically cancel an executive’s contractual entitlements.
When can an employer withhold termination payments?
The answer depends on the individual’s legal relationship with the organisation.
For employees, termination entitlements are governed by the employment contract, the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and any applicable modern award or enterprise agreement.
Under the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth), serious misconduct includes deliberate conduct inconsistent with continuing employment and conduct creating a serious and imminent risk to a person or the employer’s business. Where serious misconduct justifies summary dismissal, an employer may terminate employment without providing notice. However, outstanding entitlements, including accrued annual leave, generally remain payable.
Importantly, allegations alone are not sufficient. Employers need reliable evidence to support a finding of serious misconduct and should provide the employee with a genuine opportunity to respond before making a final decision.
For senior executives, contractual provisions may also determine whether discretionary bonuses, deferred remuneration or other benefits can be withheld or recovered.
Partners operate under a different framework. They are not automatically employees and their entitlements generally depend on the partnership agreement. A partnership agreement may contain expulsion provisions that affect capital returns, retirement benefits and other financial interests.
This distinction is particularly relevant when considering the different departure arrangements reported in the KPMG matter.
Are boards’ hands tied?
Boards can face significant constraints but they are not necessarily powerless.
Where contractual entitlements have already accrued, withholding payment without a valid legal basis can expose an organisation to breach of contract claims and other liabilities. Equally, a negotiated departure may be commercially preferable to prolonged litigation, additional disclosure and reputational damage.
However, boards may retain discretion over unvested incentives, discretionary bonuses and benefits subject to contractual conditions. Whether those amounts can be deferred, reduced or recovered depends on the applicable agreements and legal requirements.
Patrick highlights an important distinction between what the law requires and what corporate accountability demands. A payment may be legally payable while still attracting legitimate questions from shareholders, employees and the wider community.
The solution is not necessarily to disregard existing entitlements after misconduct emerges. It is to design executive remuneration arrangements that account for potential governance failures before they occur.
What should employers and HR change?
Executive employment contracts and partnership agreements should clearly define serious misconduct, identify the circumstances in which discretionary benefits may be withheld and establish appropriate investigation and decision-making procedures.
Employers should also consider:
- Malus and clawback provisions: Allowing eligible unvested remuneration to be reduced or previously paid incentives to be recovered where specified misconduct or risk-management failures occur.
- Deferred remuneration: Making certain payments conditional on the outcome of defined review or investigation processes.
- Clear termination provisions: Distinguishing accrued entitlements from discretionary payments and specifying the consequences of serious misconduct.
- Independent investigations: Ensuring allegations are assessed objectively and affected individuals have a genuine opportunity to respond.
- Consistent decision-making: Applying the same standards regardless of an individual’s seniority or position within the organisation.
These arrangements should be carefully drafted. A clawback provision cannot simply be assumed to override statutory entitlements or other legal restrictions.
Conclusion
The debate surrounding executive golden handshakes highlights the tension between contractual rights, corporate governance and public expectations of accountability.
Boards cannot simply withhold legally accrued entitlements because an executive’s departure has attracted criticism. However, they can take a more proactive approach to structuring remuneration, managing investigations and establishing enforceable mechanisms for addressing misconduct.
As Patrick’s commentary highlights, the most effective time to address these issues is before a governance crisis occurs. Clear executive agreements, appropriately structured remuneration and transparent decision-making can help organisations protect their interests while ensuring accountability is not compromised by poorly drafted arrangements.
Liquid Employment Lawyers advises Australian businesses, directors and executives on employment contracts, executive remuneration, termination arrangements and workplace investigations. Contact our team for advice on managing executive employment risks and complex departures.

